California & Massachusetts Bar  ·  USPTO Registered  ·  CIPP/US · CIPP/E · AIGP

Online Counterfeiting Enforcement: New Strategies Needed

Category: Trademark / Brand Acquisition
Reading Time: 5 minutes

Overview

Online counterfeiting enforcement faces a persistent challenge: counterfeit listings can disappear while the sellers behind them continue operating. Drawing on the American Apparel & Footwear Association's (AAFA) 2026 Notorious Markets submission, this article examines the limitations of takedown-based enforcement, the importance of identifying repeat sellers, and the legal boundaries of platform accountability. It also considers how brand owners can evaluate enforcement outcomes through seller recurrence and marketplace exposure, rather than relying exclusively on the number of listings removed.

Online counterfeiting enforcement illustration showing a removed product listing and a connected network of seller accounts.

1. Why Online Counterfeiting Enforcement Cannot Stop at Takedowns

In October 2026, AAFA nominated Facebook, Instagram, Alibaba.com, AliExpress, and DHgate for consideration in the U.S. Trade Representative's annual Notorious Markets review. According to AAFA, one member removed more than 120,000 counterfeit product listings and 24,000 fraudulent advertisements from Meta platforms during the first half of 2026.

The figures illustrate the scale of the enforcement burden facing brand owners. Yet a removed listing says little about whether the seller has ceased operating. The same products may return under different storefronts, through related accounts, or via advertising that directs consumers to independent websites.

Takedown systems can be effective at removing reported content without necessarily preventing repeated infringement. Both outcomes must be assessed separately.

2. Repeat Sellers and the Evidence Behind Enforcement

Identifying recurring infringement requires information that survives the removal of individual listings. Seller identifiers, contact details, product photographs, shipping records, and linked websites may help reveal connections between apparently separate storefronts.

Evidence preservation is particularly important. Once an offending page disappears, relevant information may become difficult to recover. For significant cases, documented purchases and transaction records may provide further insight into how counterfeit products reach consumers.

Seller-level investigations also require restraint. Similar photographs or overlapping product descriptions do not conclusively establish common ownership. A credible enforcement record distinguishes verified connections from preliminary investigative leads.

3. Platform Accountability and Its Legal Boundaries

AAFA's submission advocates stronger responses to counterfeit sales and repeat offenders. Its recommendations contribute to the policy debate surrounding online marketplaces, but nomination for the Notorious Markets List does not constitute a finding of unlawful conduct or civil liability.

U.S. trademark law makes a related distinction. In Tiffany (NJ) Inc. v. eBay Inc., 600 F.3d 93 (2d Cir. 2010), the Second Circuit held that general awareness of counterfeiting was insufficient, on its own, to establish contributory trademark infringement by the platform. More specific knowledge and the service provider's conduct were central to the analysis.

The case does not eliminate potential platform liability. It demonstrates why responsibility must be assessed under applicable legal standards and evidence rather than inferred solely from the volume of counterfeit listings.

4. Building an Online Counterfeiting Enforcement Strategy

Effective online counterfeiting enforcement begins with reliable rights documentation and a consistent record of incidents. Trademark registrations, prior complaints, seller information, and preserved evidence can help brand owners identify recurring patterns and support proportionate escalation.

Where evidence establishes repeated violations, brands may seek account-level measures under relevant platform policies. Persistent supply may also justify investigating distributors, manufacturers, or fulfillment channels, subject to the applicable jurisdiction's legal and evidentiary requirements.

These measures should form part of an ongoing brand protection program. For related issues, see Innoshield Law's Strategic Brand Protection & Enforcement overview.

5. Measuring Outcomes Beyond Removed Listings

Takedown totals remain useful operational data, but they should not be treated as the sole measure of enforcement success.

A broader assessment considers how often suspected repeat sellers return, how quickly identified infringements are addressed, and whether counterfeit products become less visible across priority marketplaces and search results.

This distinction helps brand owners separate enforcement activity from its lasting effects. A large number of removals may reflect an efficient reporting process, a substantial infringement problem, or both.

Conclusion

AAFA's 2026 submission draws attention to a persistent structural problem in digital commerce. Products, advertisements, storefronts, and fulfillment operations can be distributed across multiple platforms, making isolated content removal an incomplete response to recurring infringement.

For brand owners, the next challenge is building evidence that connects individual incidents, while respecting the legal limits governing platform accountability and enforcement.

A takedown records what has been removed. Effective enforcement also asks whether the infringement returns.

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Businesses should consult a licensed before legal or commercial decisions.


Contributors

Jane (Jie) Li

Founding Attorney

California | +1. 213. 774. 2132
jli@innoslaw.com

Kefei Wu

Director of Global Operations

Paris | +33. 6. 98. 12. 89. 80
kwu@innoslaw.com

Continue Reading

Related Articles

Infographic comparing the trademark enforcement strategies of McDonald's, Monster Energy, Apple, Chanel, and Nike.

U.S. Trademark Opposition: What Big Brands Know

From McDonald’s to Apple, established brands use trademark monitoring and opposition proceedings to protect their portfolios. Explore how U.S. trademark oppositions work, what they mean for applicants, and why early trademark clearance matters.

Read More »

Have a Legal Question?

Our attorneys are available for consultations. Get clarity on your trademark or privacy law concerns — directly from counsel.